All eyes are on Sen. Josh Hawley during the confirmation hearings for Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson and “we should all prepare for his funeral tomorrow.” Hawley made waves with a Twitter thread “cherry-picking” from Jackson’s record and speeches and suggesting she might be soft on sexual offenders where children are involved. Hawley’s sticking by his thread with a retweet of the Washington Examiner.
Nothing Sen. Hawley said about Brown Jackson has been debunked https://t.co/HfyHCOCJ9m
— Josh Hawley (@HawleyMO) March 21, 2022
We’re not sure if this fact-check was done by NBC News and picked up by NBC Chicago or if NBC Chicago did it, but either way, Will Weissert and Calvin Woodward make it clear that Republicans are “twisting” Jackson’s record.
FACT CHECK: Republicans Twist Ketanji Brown Jackson's Judicial Record https://t.co/gDfH8Drus6
— NBC Chicago (@nbcchicago) March 21, 2022
So? What about Hawley’s claim that Jackson has sentenced child sex offenders to sentences shorter than the suggested minimum guidelines? Our fact-checkers write:
She told the [sentencing] hearing she was surprised at a Justice Department expert’s testimony that, as she put it, some child-sex offenders may actually “not be pedophiles” but perhaps “loners” looking for like-minded company in child pornography circles. Being surprised by an assertion and wanting to know more are not the same as endorsing it.
…
From those questions, Hawley extrapolated that Jackson had drawn conclusions, when she hadn’t.
But several behavioral science researchers testified at that hearing that there may be nonsexual motivations among a portion of child-sex criminals. It is not a radical view. And many judges do see a distinction between those who produce child pornography and those who receive it.
It’s not a radical view among some researchers that pedophilia isn’t a crime but just another misunderstood sexual orientation. Salon was blasted last fall for “trying to mainstream pedophilia” in an article titled, “I’m a pedophile, but not a monster.” Just this January, USA Today wrote that “there’s a lot we’re misunderstanding” about pedophilia. Slate pondered if pedophilia was a crime to be punished. We note that the New York Times has deleted its repugnant headline about pedophilia. Into the memory hole it goes, along with Salon’s articles.
Recommended
So yeah, maybe she was just asking questions. That still doesn’t explain the under-sentencing of sex offenders noted in Hawley’s thread. Is it really so wrong for senators to want to clarify a Supreme Court nominee’s thinking on the issue?
Have they been as slimy as to falsely accuse her of rape?
— Ted Howze DVM (@Ted_Howze) March 21, 2022
How many beers does she drink ?
— XeroTolerance (@Samhain1313) March 21, 2022
They hire someone to allege misconduct in college?
— Tony Huneycutt 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸 (@tonyhuneyc) March 21, 2022
Fact check: you lost my confidence with "Russian misinformation" and numerous other episodes.
— Good Ole Ricky (@ricky_ole) March 21, 2022
How many false rape allegations are they making against her?
— Matt Stormer (@TopCityStormer) March 21, 2022
How many false rape allegations are they making against her?
— Matt Stormer (@TopCityStormer) March 21, 2022
She’s pro pedophile. No way to spin that. She doesn’t want pedophiles to go to jail, and wants to eliminate the sex offender registry.
No mercy for pedophile defenders.
— Inmate# 112246 (@BLM_Reject) March 21, 2022
This isn’t a fact check, at no point in your article did you disprove what he said with counter facts, you simply tried to provide context to why a thought process of normalizing pedophilia would be a possible outcome. The notion is disgusting and @NBCNews is disgusting for this
— Raikiri767 (@raikiri767) March 21, 2022
It really isn’t a fact-check at all. Take the specific cases Hawley cited, and then “fact-check” whether or not Jackson was lenient in her sentencing.
Related:
ABC News contributor thinks Josh Hawley ‘has met his match’ in Ketanji Brown Jackson ‘and we should all prepare for his funeral tomorrow’ https://t.co/p8zehN4or3
— Twitchy Team (@TwitchyTeam) March 21, 2022
Join the conversation as a VIP Member