A court in Pennsylvania just ruled that Act 77, which allowed no-excuse mail-in voting during the 2020 election, is unconstitutional:
BREAKING: Pa. Commonwealth Court rules Act 77 of 2019, allowing no-excuse mail-in voting, is unconstitutional. Judge Mary Hannah Leavitt wrote, "A constitutional amendment must be presented to the people and adopted into our fundamental law." @FOX43 https://t.co/6JStyPe7Xg
— Matt Maisel (@Matt_Maisel) January 28, 2022
Former President Trump took a victory lap on the news:
The state will appeal the ruling to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court so nothing will change at the moment:
This opinion is based on twisted logic and faulty reasoning, and is wrong on the law. It will be immediately appealed and therefore won’t have any immediate impact on Pennsylvania’s upcoming elections. https://t.co/9LvBXyw29l
— AG Josh Shapiro (@PAAttorneyGen) January 28, 2022
And Attorney General Josh Shapiro predicted the law would be upheld:
The issue will now go before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, and we are confident that Act 77 will ultimately be upheld as constitutional.
— AG Josh Shapiro (@PAAttorneyGen) January 28, 2022
In summary, the lower court is saying that the state constitution needs to be amended and these changes can’t be implemented with legislation alone:
The court notably isn’t saying mail voting is “bad” in some way — this is about the PA Constitution’s requirements for voting; how those requirements were interpreted in past cases; and how Act 77 changed election law.
— Jonathan Lai 🙊 賴柏羽 (@Elaijuh) January 28, 2022
Act 77 itself was a compromise that allowed the mail-in voting in exchange for the removal of straight-party voting and if the state Supreme Court does rule the law unconstitutional, those other provisions would reportedly be dropped, too:
Something I didn’t think about initially: In declaring Act 77 unconstitutional, not just mail voting part (there’s also a non-severability provision), the court would roll back all the changes, which included extending voter reg deadline and removal of straight-party option.
— Jonathan Lai 🙊 賴柏羽 (@Elaijuh) January 28, 2022
***
Join the conversation as a VIP Member