As Twitchy reported earlier, Marvel’s new superhero flick “Captain Marvel” was screened for critics and is getting a lot of thumbs up from reviewers who really didn’t have a lot of nice things to say about the movie.

For some reason, feminists have really taken “Captain Marvel” to heart, seeing as it’s the first Marvel movie with a female star — but that doesn’t guarantee that it won’t suck. Feminist site The Mary Sue noticed one thing: all the negative reviews are coming from men. So misogyny is at play here, just as they suspected?

The thing is, a 10-second search on review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes shows that plenty of women aren’t recommending the movie. TIME’s Stephanie Zacharek, the Associated Press’s Lindsey Bahr, and Us Weekly’s Mara Reinstein all gave it a “rotten” score.

Seriously, who cares?