The Associated Press today released new climate change writing guidance for its reporters, encouraging them to stop using the terms “skeptics” or “deniers” in favor of the word “doubters” instead.
AP Style tip: For those who don’t accept climate science or dispute world is warming from man-made forces, use climate change doubters.
— AP Stylebook (@APStylebook) September 22, 2015
Also can describe them as those who reject mainstream climate science. Avoid use of skeptics or deniers.
— AP Stylebook (@APStylebook) September 22, 2015
The change goes into effect immediately, as do other topics “deemed highly relevant to breaking news coverage;” for example, when the AP dropped the term “illegal immigrant” in 2013 in favor of a person “living in or entering a country illegally or without legal permission.”
In a blog entry, the Associated Press explained the motivation to retire the terms skeptic and denier.
Scientists who consider themselves real skeptics – who debunk mysticism, ESP and other pseudoscience, such as those who are part of the Center for Skeptical Inquiry – complain that non-scientists who reject mainstream climate science have usurped the phrase skeptic. They say they aren’t skeptics because “proper skepticism promotes scientific inquiry, critical investigation and the use of reason in examining controversial and extraordinary claims.” That group prefers the phrase “climate change deniers” for those who reject accepted global warming data and theory. But those who reject climate science say the phrase denier has the pejorative ring of Holocaust denier so The Associated Press prefers climate change doubter or someone who rejects mainstream science.
As for the term “mainstream science,” the AP explains that the theory of man-made climate change “is supported by more than 90 percent of the peer-reviewed scientific literature.”
AP memo: Climate change deniers "reject mainstream climate science."http://t.co/Cn0N2zdZFx
— Poynter (@Poynter) September 22, 2015
I actually have no quarrel with the new AP phraseology, since "mainstream climate science" is BS. http://t.co/yt1hixB2Eu
— Mark Davis (@MarkDavis) September 22, 2015
@APStylebook What is the term for "science" when it's not always "science" but instead a cause led by those pushing a political agenda?
— kenny bania (@kennybania2013) September 22, 2015
The propagandists at AP don’t even realize the phrase “climate change” is hopelessly slanted. https://t.co/d2tw4t865O
— Dan Curry (@dancurry) September 22, 2015
@dancurry Science groups AAAS, Natl Academy of Sciences, American Meteor. Society, Geol Society; Am. Physical Society all use climate change
— seth borenstein (@borenbears) September 22, 2015
.@borenbears So what? The govt. uses all kinds of jargon AP doesn’t adopt. “Climate change” is a PR phrase for failed “global warming.”
— Dan Curry (@dancurry) September 22, 2015
Plenty of people suggested other terms for those who reject mainstream science, such as “morons” and “idiots.” To be honest, we were happy with deniers.
@APStylebook They ARE denying it. Call them what they are.
— Patrick (@PatrickInNC) September 22, 2015
No apologies here.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member