Matt Drudge has broken out the siren for this one, although we’re careful now not to associate “violation of federal law” with any sort of punishment or consequences.
Fox News’ James Rosen reports tonight that “some senior U.S. officials involved in the implementation of the Iran nuclear deal” have determined that the deal violates federal law, in part because of legislation that President Obama himself signed into law in 2012.
— James Rosen (@JamesRosenFNC) October 8, 2015
At issue is a passage tucked away in ancillary paperwork attached to the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, or JCPOA, as the Iran nuclear deal is formally known. Specifically, Section 5.1.2 of Annex II provides that in exchange for Iranian compliance with the terms of the deal, the U.S. “shall…license non-U.S. entities that are owned or controlled by a U.S. person to engage in activities with Iran that are consistent with this JCPOA.”
In short, this means that foreign subsidiaries of U.S. parent companies will, under certain conditions, be allowed to do business with Iran. The problem is that the Iran Threat Reduction and Syria Human Rights Act (ITRA), signed into law by President Obama in August 2012, was explicit in closing the so-called “foreign sub” loophole.
Legal analysts say the Iran deal could be in trouble in court, as it is not a treaty but an “executive agreement” that received no vote of ratification from Congress.
Obama’s Iran Deal Violates a Law Obama Signed in 2012: http://t.co/fYiA7SiT7H
— RedState (@RedState) October 9, 2015
RedState’s Joe Cunningham isn’t expecting much to transpire either. He writes that the White House “know what they are doing is not at all legal, and they don’t care …. The White House won’t alter its course, and things will be able to go ahead without prosecution because this administration believes more in itself than it does actual law.”
@RedState -when has Obama worried about adhering to any law?
— Ron Kramer (@Rakramer73) October 9, 2015
@JamesRosenFNC OK Now what? Who's gonna be man (or woman) enough to do anything about it?
— StillAProudAmerican (@dpvar2) October 9, 2015
@JamesRosenFNC Well, they got the easy part done. Now for the hard part. What exactly are they going to DO about it.
— DanCrocker (@Dan__Crocker) October 8, 2015
@JamesRosenFNC what they will do about it is NOTHiNG!
— Kevin Cullen (@KevinCullen67) October 8, 2015
@JamesRosenFNC do you honestly think Republican leadership will do something about this?
— Janice (@gojangirl) October 8, 2015
— BoSox Fan in VA (@KennethMoura) October 8, 2015
@JamesRosenFNC didnt the Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei just say no more negotiations with the US?
— Brian Dreyer (@Bwdreyer) October 8, 2015
Yes. Further negotiations with the United States are banned. And why not? Iran got everything it wanted and more.
* * *