For an author nothing is as exciting as getting your manuscript accepted by a publishing house. You slave over your work for who knows how long, having confidence that the story that you have to tell is interesting enough to be published and you'll be able to see your name emblazoned on the cover of a book that will perhaps change the perspectives of those who read it.
Finally your book finds a home, is announced by St. Martin's Press... and then some random other person throws a highly public fit about your race not being appropriate to be allowed to write this book.
as a wellesley student and a macmillan author, i'm troubled by the concept of this book, written + edited by wellesley alums and published by an imprint of my publisher. pretty sure we agreed a while ago that white people shouldn't write plots centered on racism and BIPOC trauma? https://t.co/LGpM2kkgoO
— ann zhao says preorder dear wendy (@annzhao_) November 3, 2023
'We all agreed' did we? Maybe that item on the last election ballot was in very small print so we overlooked it?
The description of the book in the announcement by the author (which has since been taken down) says it's:
about a young woman spending the summer with her wealthy aunt and uncle in Greenwich, CT, who develops an obsessive crush on the family's Black nanny and must decide who to protect after a tragic accident occurs, exploring the insidiousness of privilege and complicity and the ways that whiteness and power protect their own.'
We're going to be honest; this doesn't sound like a page turner to us. But it seems like the sort of thing that gets published these days, hits all the right culture war notes of being an important book... and like we said, when did we all agree that white people can only ever write about white people?
Woke author is “troubled by the concept” of a book, therefore the book that she hasn’t read should not be published. Why? The author is white and her novel has a black character. I’m so sick of these mindless Woke termites decimating culture. https://t.co/S5yl43KJPt
— Joseph Massey (@jmasseypoet) November 4, 2023
Narrator: No one agreed to this. https://t.co/cvZ1oUMxxQ
— Rich Horton (@PurePopPub) November 4, 2023
huge surprise—a YA author is pissed off someone else might take away attention from their upcoming YA novel so they call their perceived rival a bigot. i havent seen this script play out two thousand times before from YA writers https://t.co/naAnC0wcze
— le loup garou (@turdducken) November 4, 2023
Jealousy and the impulse to destroy someone else in your way rise from this tweet like fetid heat. Go be a worthwhile person and not this monster you are right now. https://t.co/k8VhBsWctF
— John Podhoretz (@jpodhoretz) November 4, 2023
And it's hard to see this as anything but jealousy. The author of the book under discussion, Kate Broad, is a reasonably established author who has published ten books under a penname in the past, including one that was 'Top Pick' from Oprah Magazine. Ann Zhao is apparently a linguistics student at Wellsley who's graduating next year and is the author of a forthcoming book... and if you're going to complain about someone else's book maybe your own book shouldn't look like this...
COVER REVEAL!!!!! art by betsy cola, design by julia bianchi!
— ann zhao says preorder dear wendy (@annzhao_) April 18, 2023
dear wendy is about two aroace college students who hate each other’s online love advice personas but are actually friends in real life (oops). out 4/16/24!! and you can preorder now!!! see the replies!!! pic.twitter.com/vQbCzSIy2s
In case you're wondering 'aroace' apparently is a portmanteau of 'Aromantic' and 'Asexual'... we had to look that one up. Zhao seems to have inserted a bunch of modern progressive tropes into the plot of the classic
Ernst Lubitsch film 'The Shop Around the Corner'. Very innovative.
No one agreed to this lol https://t.co/sYYMZwia7q
— Noam Blum 🚡 (@neontaster) November 4, 2023
No, we didn’t agree on that. https://t.co/fkrdEdJE3B
— Amy Curtis 🇮🇱 (@RantyAmyCurtis) November 4, 2023
I hereby grant everyone the permission to write about anything they want.
— Sharmi (@iamsharmi_) November 4, 2023
Ann, there is no more we. This is a free country and people can write about whatever they want. A white woman writing about BIPOC trauma is akin to walking a mile in the shoes of the oppressed. https://t.co/QlmCaLD9bN
Well that settles it, Broad's book should be a-okay then, right?
It feels strange to write in defense of such a pandering book as Broad's appears to be, but there are things worse than pandering and being a censorious scold because of an authors position on the intersectional oppression stack is definitely one of those. Zhao's book seems to come out this upcoming April and we'll be sure not to buy it... not that there was much chance of that happening anyway.
***
Editor's Note: Do you enjoy Twitchy's conservative reporting taking on the radical left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth. Join Twitchy VIP and use the promo code SAVEAMERICA to get 40% off your VIP membership!
Join the conversation as a VIP Member