Is New York's 7-round magazine capacity limit a backdoor ban on semi-automatic handguns?

New York’s new gun law imposes a seven-round magazine capacity limit on handguns.

As Anna Rittgers notes, “there are blindingly few semiautomatic handguns manufactured to hold magazines with a maximum capacity of only seven rounds.”

Some Twitter users say this means that the majority of semi-automatic handguns in New York will be illegal.

@hannityshow So the new gun law in NY has made most all self defense handguns illegal since most semi-automatic handguns have 10 rnd clips

— Jerry Rogers (@JerryLRogers) January 16, 2013

https://twitter.com/LogicalSkeptic/status/291506649921892352

@gunexpert As a NY'er, if my pistol has more than 7 rounds in the magazine in MY OWN HOME, it is now illegal. Absolute lunacy.

— Tom Dennison (@ThomasDennison1) January 16, 2013

Glad I don’t live in NY. It’s illegal to own a clip that has more than 7 rounds in it? That’s a little ridiculous.

— Александр (@alexandrT_) January 16, 2013

https://twitter.com/PapaBartik/status/291406988506705920

The standard 4 ammunition is 10 rounds & now NYC law made it 7 – that means all those celebrity bodyguards are illegal, most of NY & police

— Averebely (@AVerebely) January 16, 2013

@FraggleStikkCar NY Law any magazine over 7 rounds is now illegal.WTH?No grandfather clause.Most ppl have at least 10rounds.

— Kelly (@flyoverangel) January 16, 2013

Similar comments at Glock Talk:

“It’s an attempt at a back door ban on most pistols. Cuomo picked 7 because all the gun manufacturers currently make 10 round mags for the restrictive states and New York is hoping the manufacturers will not want to make 7 rounders just for New York.”

“My guess is that it’s a back door ban: no one makes 7-round mags, and I doubt manufacturers will jump on the bandwagon for NY…”

Recommended

WOMP WOMP! Hims Stock Tanks After CEO Praises 'Moral Courage' of Antisemitic Campus Protesters

Amy Curtis

Advertisement

Others say handguns with ten-round magazines are grandfathered provided the user loads only seven rounds:
https://twitter.com/BMIT24/status/291357408486379522

So the new gun law will grandfather in pistols w 10 rounds. But it is illegal to load them w more than 7 rounds. Good luck w that!! Lol

— Bills_Chick (@Bills_Chick) January 16, 2013

Guns that had been legal but r being banned would b grandfathered in, but their owners must register their firearms w the state or sell them

— Los Melendez (@simplylos16) January 16, 2013

Many gun owners simply aren’t sure what the law means.

@l1zzard74 @AnthonyCumia I think it would have to be modified to only hold 7. Could be wrong though

— John (@da_bully) January 16, 2013

Much more discussion here and here.

We hope officials in New York will clear up the confusion by issuing a definitive statement.

Related:

#SelfDefenseInNY: Choose your Cuomo-approved useless weapon

New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo ‘overpowers the extremists,’ signs package of extensive gun regulations into law