As our own Warren Squire reported on Thursday morning, ABC News secured an interview with one of the two low-testosterone beta male jurors who wanted to acquit child murderer Lindsay Clancy. Nick Dargie said he was "devastated" that he couldn't set Clancy free, and complained that the lone holdout didn't have "a single piece of evidence or witness testimony that he used to prove why he was thinking the way he was." He continued, "There was — there was several times we would ask him to show us, like, evidence or, you know, describe a witness testimony that helped to prove what he was saying."
The lone holdout did provide a demonstration to help prove what he was saying, wrapping an exercise band around a water bottle to mimic how Clancy systematically killed her three children. Dargie says the demonstration was "disgusting."
Here was more from Lindsay Clancy juror Nick Dargie, whining about the single male juror who wanted to find her guilty and calling the juror’s behavior at one point “disgusting”....
— Curtis Houck (@CurtisHouck) September 10, 2026
“There was times he wouldn’t engage. Like, he’d be scrolling on his phone while people were… pic.twitter.com/lNbaGIrVHa
The post continues:
… talking to him. You know, things like that.”
“He took the exercise band out of the bag, grabbed an empty water bottle, and — and tied the band around the water bottle and pulled it.
“I think I was just so shocked that he did [mimic how Clancy killed her children].”
“I was shocked. It didn’t make any sense to me. Like, we’re not in here to play detective, or it’s not a game of Clue. Like, this is serious. I asked him why. Why was why? Why are you doing that?”
“It’s disgusting.”
So, he was disgusted by the lone holdout tying an exercise band around an empty water bottle, but devastated that he couldn't free Clancy, who tied an exercise band around the necks of her three children, ages 8 months through 5 years, and strangled the life out of them.
You know what's more disgusting?
— J (@JayTC53) September 10, 2026
11 jurors wanting to let a child mass murderer off the hook.
The man bitching is disgusting.
— Helen Crabtree (@merecitizen1913) September 10, 2026
The man amplifying him more so.
Both are useless.
The more these assholes talk, the more I like the holdout.
— Senator Beauregard Claghorn (@SenBeauClaghorn) September 10, 2026
Has to be a liberal to think putting a band around a water bottle is disgusting but the strangulation of three children isn't disgusting enough to find her guilty of murder.
— StOrMyNiGhT (@Nautiguy48) September 10, 2026
He was probably trying to remind you all of what she did.
— Apollo10 (@BodieIsland1) September 10, 2026
Being a pussy in front of the camera isn't making the point I think he thinks he is making.
— Daniel 🇺🇸 (@TomHillsisyphus) September 10, 2026
Wait - so now you’re saying there were _ten_ women on the jury?
— Pi Guy (@Piguy_3point14) September 10, 2026
That explains so much.
This beta "male" is exactly as I imagined. What a low-T weakling. 😡
— Based Jane Doh 🇺🇸✝️ (@BasedMaryKay) September 10, 2026
I, too, would find it really gross if someone was refusing to logically engage with me and the responsibility the law gave us to apply it and used props to violently imply that he is above such things by reason of his moral outrage at the underlying crime.
— Not a Good Jewish Girl✡️ (@estherzelda0514) September 10, 2026
This guy definitely seems more emotionally affected by what the juror did with the band than what the defendant did with it. This is the most bizarre time we're living in right now!
— ZSteve (@z_steve7340) September 10, 2026
He was triggered by a water bottle but not the real evidence of the exercise bands, pjs the kids were wearing, proven length of time it took to strangle each child, and the proven premeditation of walking each child one-by-one to their death.
— Scrappy McLovin (@ScrappyMcLovin) September 10, 2026
We're guessing the lone holdout didn't find defense attorney Kevin Reddington as "funny" and "entertaining" as the other 11 jurors.
***