One country diva, an unnamed female rival, and Carrie Underwood’s groupies all went wild on Twitter late last night. Fans were still trying to catch up on the fisticuffs this afternoon. Apparently, it was over a boy.

Here’s what Alaina started tweeting in the wee hours:

Carrie Underwood, of course, is married. But many Twitter users seem to think Alaina and Underwood are the combatants.

Oh, what a tangled web. Sounds like someone’s next country hit single…