For once, Slate writer Matthew Yglesias is right. He is confused.
His confusion comes in the wake of Ramesh Ponnuru’s observation that the Congressional Budget Office thinks the Gang of Eight bill will reduce future illegal immigration by only 25 percent.
In response, Yglesias states that the only two options on immigration reform are (a) the status quo (that is, a zero percent reduction in illegal immigration) and (b) the Gang of Eight amnesty bill (a 25 percent reduction).
Aha, here we get to the heart of the matter:
At least Ygelsias admits it. Too bad other proponents of the Gang of Eight bill aren’t so honest.