The long national wait is over! The White House has finally seen fit to address the popular petition to deport Piers Morgan over his asinine remarks on the Second Amendment:

Let’s not let arguments over the Constitution’s Second Amendment violate the spirit of its First. President Obama believes that the Second Amendment guarantees an individual right to bear arms. However, the Constitution not only guarantees an individual right to bear arms, but also enshrines the freedom of speech and the freedom of the press — fundamental principles that are essential to our democracy. Americans may disagree on matters of public policy and express those disagreements vigorously, but no one should be punished by the government simply because he or she expressed a view on the Second Amendment — or any other matter of public concern.

We’re glad the White House is standing up for Piers Morgan’s First Amendment rights. We just wish we could be confident it would stand up for Second Amendment rights, too.

  • Peyton

    Does Piers actually have 1st Amendment rights considering he’s not a citizen? I guess it applies to him when he moved here?

    • NachoCheese (D)

      The Constitution is applicable to all persons that fall within the jurisdiction of the United States, citizen and non-citizen alike.

      • mickeyco

        Don’t know if I’m misunderstanding you. The article points out that he has the right to free speech but is not guaranteed the right to be here.

        • NachoCheese (D)

          Correct. Musket has no Constitutional right to his presence here in the U.S., but while he is here (hopefully not long), our Constitutional rights are applicable to him (unless of course they are expressly reserved for citizens – i.e. voting).

          EDIT: see post by “ike” in this thread regarding the limitations of 1st Amendment rights of foreign nationals as established by Supreme Court decisions.

      • BeautifulAmerica

        That’s not true. Non-citizens do not have the same protections.

  • Dwight Spainhoward

    Of course they are not going to deport someone that is trying to destroy the United

    states from the inside out by getting the citizens to turn on themselves, Mr. President don’t you have the duty to protect the country from attack? Well Piers Morgan is using the Media as a weapon to attack from within.

    • BeautifulAmerica

      Duty, schmuty.
      Attacking America from within is what obammao is here for.

  • Lftcoaster

    So POTUS says the Constitution guarentees the right to bear arms, but Biden says… The president is going to act. . . . There are going to be executive
    orders, executive action that can be taken. We haven’t decided what that
    is yet, but we’re compiling it all.
    Obama is going to enact laws by EO? That’s unconstitutional.

    • Elaine

      It’s kind of funny that Joe Biden is in charge of the gun control task force. He LOVES HIS guns, especially his Beretta! Plus Obama says THIS: hahahaha

    • BeautifulAmerica

      You got it!
      And so does the author of your avatar.
      Impeach obammao.

    • Trudy Hill

      Everytime I see the letters POTUS.. I think of someone with a lisp.. piece of thit of the us.

      • Hello Jerry (D)

        Whit the current Occupier I leave out “TU”.

    • Trudy Hill

      Everytime I see the letters POTUS.. I think of someone with a lisp.. piece of thit of the us.

  • independentjones

    Hadn’t heard from ‘Musket’ for more than a day … wrongly assumed that he’d already been deported.

    Sad day, indeed.

    • AMERICAN Kafir™(KAdams)

      We should really let the shunning commence.

  • Tony Lima

    As is so often the case, James Taranto has written extensively about this at Since that’s probably behind a paywall, here are two relevant paragraphs:

    “In response Morgan tweeted: “Ironic U.S. gun rights campaign to deport me for ‘attacking 2nd Amendment rights’ – is my opinion not protected under 1st Amendment rights?” We tweeted back: “Your opinion is protected, your presence in the U.S. is not.”

    We directed Morgan to Kleindienst v. Mandel, a 1972 case in which the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the denial of a visa to “a Belgian journalist and Marxian theoretician” who had been invited to an academic conference in America. This led to a bit of confusion, as the Daily Caller published a story titled “Wall Street Journal Columnist Explains on Twitter How to Deport Piers Morgan.””

    • NachoCheese (D)

      FYI, no paywall, I can read the whole article.

    • BeautifulAmerica

      Thanks, Tony

  • Revolution_WILL_be_tweeted!

    You can’t be deported but you’re still retarded. What kind of fool hates guns when his last name is pronounced MORE GUN?

  • ike

    In lazily arguing, “Let’s not let arguments over the Constitution’s Second Amendment violate the spirit of its First,” Carney is implying that Piers Morgan’s anti-gun crusade is protected by free speech under the first amendment when it clearly isn’t since foreign nationals do not have absolute first amendment rights.

    The fact that the first amendment does not apply to non-citizens was established in the Supreme Court’s affirmation of Bluman v. FEC in January 2012. The court’s decision rubber-stamped a District Court decision which found under its first amendment analysis that, “The United States has a compelling interest in limiting the participation of foreign citizens in such activities, and “thereby preventing foreign influence over the U.S. political process.”

    Legal precedent also dictates that foreign nationals can be deported from the United States for subversion against the Constitution. In Harisiades v. Shaugnessy (1952), the US Supreme Court upheld Harisiades’ deportation by ruling that the first amendment did not protect Harisiades’ membership of the Communist Party.

    In issuing its glib response, the White House has completely failed to even address these cases and has erroneously claimed that the first amendment applies to non-citizen foreign nationals like Piers Morgan, when it does not.

    The fact that the White House’s response was timed to coincide precisely with the national media furore over Alex Jones’ appearance on CNN’s Piers Morgan Tonight is also curiously synchronous, given that Jones was the author of the original petition and Morgan is a personal friend of the Obama’s.

    • ricci

      not surprising as obama has been and continues to trample all over the constitution he could care less what it says

    • BeautifulAmerica


      obamao perverts the true meaning of our Constitution every chance he gets. Thats what he’s here for.

      Foreign nationals are here as guests, and SHOULD be deported when they preach subversion. They were…back when people were concerned about our Country.

    • ProgTrog

      My thoughts exactly.

      We still have laws on the books that prevent foreigners from owning radio stations here because of Hitler, we should look into updating those laws to prevent foreigners, especially the British, from owning tv stations or newspapers here as well. We can’t let foreign propagandists,like Piers Morgan, “exercise their (non-existent) First Amendment rights” to the detriment of OUR rights.

      Our rights are OUR rights. The foreigners don’t deserve them, and they just want to take them away from US by using one right to undermine another anyway.

    • mdtljt

      Well said, Ike…take it to ’em!!!

  • madian_kikyou

    Oh COME ON!

  • tredglx

    If Auntie and Uncle 0bama can stay after being outed as illegals, what makes anyone think ‘Teh Won™’ would send Muskets packing?

  • GMJP

    REMEMBER! The 1st amendment that you keep referring to protects his ‘opinion’ NOT his right to be in this country!!

  • Cruizin1960

    The White House got it wrong. The 1st Amendment protects Morgan from prosecution for what he says. It does not protect his presence in the US. SCOTUS ruled on this in 1972 when the Nixon administration refused a visa to a journo from a communist bloc country.

  • Renny

    I got the email for signing. Lame. Since when does Barry care about any of the Constitutional amendments? That was a big ‘I don’t care’ to the petition. Golly, gee thanks for the lesson. *head pat*

    • tredglx

      Yeah, I did too; was yours from Opie Carney?

      • BeautifulAmerica

        The petition now should be done again, this time with the correct wording regarding foreigners.

  • Steve_J

    How about that. It puts him in the same company as Aunt Zeituni and Uncle Onyango, also undesirable aliens.

  • stuckinIL4now

    Let’s deport Obamuh instead–I’m pretty sure there’s no end to nations out there who will take him.

    • BeautifulAmerica

      I second the motion.

      • Hello Jerry (D)


  • Jack Deth


    Mr. Morgan could still wake up after a weekend bender and find himself on a Portuguese tramp steamer headed to Kuala Lumpur or Johnson Island.

    I can dream, can’t I?

  • bonnieblue2A

    Piers uses his green card and globalist run media to be the mouthpiece for the Obama administration’s gun grabbing platform. Additionally, he threatens to have a guest shot and is given cover by the White House.

    When foreign subversives are coddled and defended as the White House attacks the 2nd Amendment and law abiding gun owning citizens, can tyranny really be far behind?

    Every citizen a sentinel for liberty. Do not allow the Constitutional Republic to fall on our watch!

  • Hello Jerry (D)

    Zero isn’t going to stab one of his buddies in the back.

  • Danny Wheeler

    Geesh! Let’s have Twitchy mock him outta the USA instead!

  • GTFOBigGovt

    I’m betting he’s not here on a green card but on a work visa. Plan B = CNN reshuffle.

  • Tom Henry

    No worries, musket. Your ratings prove how much your show stinks.

  • TocksNedlog

    The president determined that having a show on CNN is punishment enough.

  • BeeKaaay

    I wish the White House would stand up for the first amendment rights of NON MARXISTS.

    That’s too much to expect.

  • OwnItObama
  • RblDiver

    So, they responded to this one, but did they ever address the secession petitions?

  • Rulz

    I still can’t believe the White House actually responds to nonsense like this.

    The pro-gun lobby sure hasn’t been doing itself too many favors with Piers Morgan lately.

    People need to calm down and look at the facts, which are on our side as they almost always are.

    -Areas with conceal/carry are even safer than Europe

    -Mass shootings are much more prone in areas with gun control

    -Gun control cities have several times the murder rate. In places, more Americans were dying from violence in gun control areas than in wars

    -Gun control in this country wasn’t dreamt up by some utopian free-thinker. It was pushed in New York because big crime bosses were tired of victims shooting back at their thugs.

    Emotional tirades on the internet and CNN is exactly how we got the election results of 06, 08, and 12.