‘That’s not logical’: Tweeter offers Spock-tastic answer to Leonard Nimoy question

Leonard Nimoy was curious about the “stand your ground” law in Florida, and received a response that briefly but effectively answered the question in a most logical manner:

Mr. Spock himself couldn’t have said it better.

  • Night Owl

    I thought he was dead. Guess not.

    • Jeff Coil

      No that was Doc McCoy

      • IBXNJ

        Scottie too

    • Zathras11 @B5

      And Sulu. No, wait, he is gay.

  • gretathegreek


  • John Howard

    If Trayvon hadn’t punched Zimmerman, there’d have been no tribble at all.

    • SpinMeNot

      Does this explain why tribbles squeal every time BHO enters the room?

      • http://whatandever.blogspot.com/ Osumashi Kinyobe

        They squeal when Michelle enters the room.


    • Nathan Stewart

      If Trayvon had STOPPED at a punch, it would have ended there. It was the continued assault and violence that threatened permanent damage, if not death, that brought it to where it ended up. As Sun Tsu stated, ALWAYS give your enemy a way out, unless total destruction is your goal.

      • http://commentspammersmustdie.blogspot.com/ Kakarot

        . . . unless total destruction is your goal.

        And in that case, be careful the battle does not end with your own destruction. (that may not be in there, but it should)

  • waltermitty2012

    If only Zimmerman’s phaser had been set on stun.

    • ked5

      or full – then there wouldn’t have been a body.

  • TocksNedlog

    His question indicates two-dimensional thinking.

  • carla5731

    You can’t explain Stand Your Ground to people whose political instincts tell them it’s better that a woman is raped than that she carry a gun.

    Some Stand Your Ground laws require that you attempt to retreat if you feel threatened. Trayvon Martin had ample time to do that, as the defense demonstrated during closing. He could have gone home, knocked on a neighbor’s door and asked for help or called 911, but he chose to sucker punch George Zimmerman.

    • mike_in_kosovo

      Some Stand Your Ground laws require that you attempt to retreat if you feel threatened.

      Since the basis of SYG law is the antithesis of your statement, can you provide examples?

      From wiki: In the United States, stand-your-ground law states that a person may justifiably use force in self-defense when there is reasonable belief of an unlawful threat, without an obligation to retreat first.

      • Stephen L. Hall

        That explains why liberals want to get rid of Stand Your Ground laws . . . they ALWAYS feel threatened.

        • Brian McKinny

          And they always prefer retreat over defending yourself from a criminal element.

          • Bathing Suit Area

            Shoot first and ask questions later.

          • thetreyman

            what? who’s saying that?

          • Ronald Green

            It’s just BSA throwing his usual BS and ignorant crap around.

          • Mark81150

            No one..

            BSA is projecting again.. just like every liberal, if you hold a principle they don’t, your motives have to be.. “Yahooo” or some other left wing fever swamp imagining of what we mean when we speak.. they can never take our words at face value.. they always assume we’re fill in the blank kind of evil..

            Something which shows just how dark and twisted their minds are when you disagree with them… we aren’t permitted to have good intentions or moral positions.. they think only they are allowed.

            which is why liberals don’t have non liberal friends much.. the most openly bigoted haters in this country, are the mind made up liberals and their absurd belief in their own pious moral superiority. A true liberal is by nature insufferable..

          • Mark81150

            You take great pride in distorting what’s being said..

            don’t you junior?

            If you are too intellectually stunted to understand the concept of self defense.. then why bother commenting here, other than to display your deeply held ignorance.

      • Guest

        wiki is not a credible source. Try Again.

        • mike_in_kosovo

          Prove the quoted piece in incorrect, first.

          Then, we can have a discussion about using wiki as a general source and point to research from…once you get brave enough to “try again” and log in under your own screen name.

        • tuxkatz

          See Florida Statutes 776.013(3)
          Says the same thing as wiki and I’m sure you’d agree that’s a credible source.

          Just because wiki is not always credible doesn’t mean it’s never credible. Like what mike_in_kosovo said, it’s a good general source of information to use as a starting point.

          Try again.

      • Guest

        wiki is not a credible source. Try Again.

  • Sarah Lise

    Maybe another Vulcan can explain it to him, since he seems to no longer possess any logic.

    • Brian McKinny

      Maybe his logic is suffering from the effects of Bendii Syndrome? After all, his father, Sarek of Vulcan suffered from it as well. It’s probably a genetic predisposition to the disease, passed down from father to son. LLAP, Spock, son of Sarek. May you find someone suitable to mind meld with to boost your control of your emotions.

      • Deborah Hallsted

        That was beautiful response. Good on ‘ya.

        • Brian McKinny

          Why, thank you, Deborah! :)

      • Sarah Lise


  • TDS

    Spock’s illogical human half is showing through…
    …and it’s a Liberal!!!

    • Stephen L. Hall

      Spock was always illogical . . . and liberal.

      The needs of the many . . . pure socialist nonsense.

      • Brian McKinny

        I always thought so, myself.

      • James ‘Jim’ Osborne

        To be fair, the context (in the movie) of his using the phrase “The needs of the many…” was as a member of the military (Star Fleet), and involved personal sacrifice in trade for the lives of his friends and shipmates. In that context, it’s not socialism-it’s heroism. (Yeah, I know how lame this post makes me look, but I’m bored…lol)

        • Brian McKinny

          Starfleet isn’t military.

  • http://www.amazon.com/Devon-Dibley-His-Golden-Key/dp/1484181557/ M F Scotto

    Why did we attack Japan? Didn’t they have a right to stand their ground?

    /Leftist Idiocy

    • John Howard

      The right perhaps, but not the capability. Oh, and there’s that quest for world domination thing they had going on.

      • King Leer

        I believe they wanted the Western Pacific, not the world. Something about Adolf and Uncle Joe getting in the way.

    • JeffWRidge

      After all, the Germans were the ones who bombed Pearl Harbor.


      (Sorry, but I couldn’t resist)

    • steven kern

      i believe a little thing called Pear Harbor had something to do with why we attacked Japan

  • thohan

    Leonard Nimoy is a guy I just can’t dislike, so I’ll assign this to dementia. Also, Star Trek III.

    • SpinMeNot

      Star Trek V was one of his as well I believe … Even my beloved trekkie wife got up and said “we’re leaving.” 30 minutes into the movie.

      • Brian McKinny

        Actually, Star Trek V was Shatner’s fiasco… But I digress. LLAP! 😀

        • SpinMeNot

          I stand corrected … thank you sir

      • David_Rogers

        V was Shatner. And Nimoy did IV, too. Whale Trek was nearly as good as Khan.

        • SpinMeNot

          I stand corrected, thank you sir.

      • ked5

        ST IV was nimoy’s – it had crossover success with non-trekkies. V was shatner’s debacle.

        • TexSizzle

          In general, the odd-numbered ones were considerably inferior to the even-numbered ones. My younger sister, a serious trekkie, said they should have released toe odds directly to videotape (yes, youngsters, some of them are that old) and only released the evens to theaters.

  • VotingForZombieReagan2016

    Spock and Wesley – going where no idiots have gone before. May they just keep going.

    • Finrod Felagund

      Troi’s actress is just as bad, sadly.

  • Danny Wheeler


  • RichardBlaine

    It’s hell watching your childhood heros grow old and feeble-minded.

  • Agent_Zeero

    SYG was not a factor n the case, so his comment is even more idiotic

  • SherryPM72

    He forgot to do the Vulcan salute. I would add that not everyone can perform a perfect nerve pinch..

  • AmericanMom

    Leonard’s comment is on the ‘fringe.’

    • Grandma HeadInjury


      • AmericanMom

        He’s still alive in our dimension.

    • http://whatandever.blogspot.com/ Osumashi Kinyobe

      Maybe the real Nimoy is in the alternate universe!

      • AmericanMom

        Smiling here and knowing you understand the “fringe” reference.

        • http://whatandever.blogspot.com/ Osumashi Kinyobe

          This message was done on a typewriter. :)

          • AmericanMom

            Ditto here. Nemoy’s mission must be corrected.

  • Ty Mcwilliams

    Don’t think SYG comes into play when you are pinned to the ground getting your head pummeled.

  • http://boogieforward.us/ K-Bob

    Zimmerman should have known how to do that Vulcan shoulder grip thing, where it totally knocks out the other guy without any harm to him whatsoever.

  • http://commentspammersmustdie.blogspot.com/ Kakarot

    Don’t confuse Leonard Nimoy with Mr. Spock.

    Or with logic.

    • bluewaternavy

      Nimrod always used to complain “I Am Not Spock”
      Sure as hell, he’s RIGHT! Spock was logical

      • Brian McKinny

        He came out with a book called, “I AM Spock”, later… :)

    • MarcusFenix

      Or William Bell, who is pretty evil…. 😉

  • The Official Andy ®

    JUST STOP TALKING, LEONARD! I don’t want to add you to my list of Hollyweirdos I won’t patronize… stop talking and enjoy your Star Trek money.


      Certainly the best post here.


      Certainly the best post here.

  • Charles Drake

    Lenny tried to pick my girlfriend up in 1972 at ISU. Cool dude.

  • Richard Jefferies

    He did have a right to stand his ground, he chose to advance on Zimmerman’s ground instead; and he got shot.

  • http://stressjudocoaching.yolasite.com/ Rick Carter, Stress Judo Coach

    Actually, Trayvon had the right to ignore zimmerman and just keep walking. zimmerman nor a real cop could have forced a stop.
    There is no reason to talk to strangers on the street, especially if you think they are following you.

  • arrow2010

    Fortunately the real Spock would not have said such a dumbass thing.

  • screamingmad

    Please pay attention. The trial was not about Stand Your Ground. It was about self defense. Self defense……when someone is attacking you and you fear great bodily harm or death it is legal to defend yourself. It is about the victims state of mind. Stand your ground was not an issue.

  • Skevvy

    If Trayvon had killed Zimmerman, we would never have heard either of their names, nor would we have been told, by the mainstream media, the race hustlers, or Hollywood, to care! For the modern American mentality, “Black teen kills white/latino neighbor” is NOT news…

    • Brian

      Because if Trayvon had killed Zimmerman, he’d have been arrested that same night. The whole reason we found out about this was that Zimmerman was barely even questioned, and was sent home that same night, gun in hand.

  • slobbering fits

    That’s retarded , Sir.

  • Mellisa621267

    Another brainless TV actor idiot! I wish that whole town would just fall off the map and leave the rest of us in peace. There is Not a whole brain among them.

  • Guest

    Paid actors should stick to the script, If there isn’t one it’s because you have no part in this play.

  • http://www.nleomf.org/officers/ FlatFoot

    Leonard, Leonard, Leonard… seriously? C’mon, Lenny!

  • http://whatandever.blogspot.com/ Osumashi Kinyobe

    Does anyone remember when these guys were on “Star Trek” and just did the things they did on the show and that was it?

    Those were the days…

  • The Official Andy ®

    Stevie Wonder has stated he will no longer play in any State with a SYG law on the books. That means he will no longer be performing in 22 States. A radical, bold move for a 63 year old millionaire who has body guards 24/7.

  • chetnapier

    Every time i read some actors opinion on these sites i am reminded of that old hollyweird saying about how you are only as good as your last success